Land of the Free

North Dakota Wants to Arrest Democracy Now!’s Amy Goodman for Engaging in Journalism . The independent journalist was documenting private security personnel using dogs to attack Native Americans activists.

So much for the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States.

Despite well-established freedom of the press protections that outline and guarantee the rights of reporters who cover breaking news stories—including confrontations between demonstrators and authorities—North Dakota officials have charged Democracy Now! host Amy Goodman with criminal trespassing after she documented private security personnel’s use of dogs to attack Native American foes of the Dakota Access Pipeline project.

Video footage obtained by Goodman, an internationally respected and frequently honored independent journalist, helped to alert Americans to the tactics being used to stop demonstrations against the pipeline by the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe and their allies. On Friday, the Obama administration halted work on key portions of the $3.8 billion pipeline project—recognizing concerns raised by the tribe and environmental activists.

That might have been expected to temper the zeal of local officials in North Dakota’s Morton County—who issued warrants charging Green Party presidential candidate Jill Stein and her vice-presidential running mate Ajamu Baraka with criminal trespass and criminal mischief after they joined the demonstrations Tuesday. But on Saturday afternoon, North Dakota’s Dickinson Press reported that:

Authorities have issued an arrest warrant for Amy Goodman of New York for a Class B misdemeanor, according to court documents.

Goodman, a reporter for the independent news program, can be seen on news footage from Sept. 3 documenting the clash between protesters and private security personnel with guard dogs at a Dakota Access construction site, including footage showing people with bite injuries and a dog with blood on its mouth.

The video footage has been widely cited by people who have since criticized the use of dogs by the security personnel.

Goodman has been open and outspoken with regard to her reporting from North Dakota.

In a detailed account of events that took place on September 3, the day the dogs were used, Goodman and Denis Moynihan wrote that “security guards attempted to repel the land defenders, unleashing at least half a dozen vicious dogs, who bit both people and horses. One dog had blood dripping from its mouth and nose. Undeterred, the dog’s handler continued to push the dog into the crowd. The guards pepper-sprayed the protesters, punched and tackled them. Vicious dogs like mastiffs have been used to attack indigenous peoples in the Americas since the time of Christopher Columbus and the Spanish conquistadors who followed him. In the end, the violent Dakota Access guards were forced back.”

Goodman’s accounts helped to raise awareness of the pipeline fight at a critical stage. And her assessment of the struggle has helped to put it in historical and contemporary context. “The battle against the Dakota Access Pipeline is being waged as a renewed assertion of indigenous rights and sovereignty, as a fight to protect clean water, but, most importantly, as part of the global struggle to combat climate change and break from dependence on fossil fuels,” Goodman and Moynihan wrote. “At the Sacred Stone, Red Warrior and other camps at the confluence of the Missouri and Cannonball rivers, the protectors are there to stay, and their numbers are growing daily.”

That is a fair assessment. It is also fair to say that an arrest warrant will not keep Amy Goodman from speaking up.

“This is unacceptable violation of freedom of the press,” Goodman said Saturday. “I was doing my job by covering pipeline guards unleashing dogs and pepper spray on Native American protesters.”

Her assertion is backed up by a constitutional amendment that reads: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.”

That amendment applies everywhere, and to officials at every level of government—even those serving in Morton County, North Dakota.

17 thoughts on “Land of the Free

  1. I posted about this also on Friday and again today. Glad to see that the Obama Administration stepped in to stop the digging but appalled at the arrest warrant for Goodman. Thanks again, Dermott, for drawing my attention to this.

  2. There seems to be an increase in attempts to censor/restrict people lately, not just reporters, and not just in the US.
    Twitter suspended an account today because they criticised a reporter.
    There’s also FB trying to censor the iconic photograph from Vietnam of the girl who was a victim of a napalm attack. Apparently they are also in talks with Israel about not allowing certain posts.
    And not forgetting here in Ireland the ongoing concerns that RTE are actively ignoring some news stories.
    I wonder how far things will go in not allowing people an opinion.

  3. 1.There is the Letter of The Law and there is the Spirit of The Law.
    As a Civil Servant (long gone) of 40+ years I am suspicious of folk who use the Letter of The Law .
    2. There is always this inherent problem shared between people and organisations: They both like to make the Truth variable

      • Where there’s a will there’s way, I suppose.
        However unlike the old publicity mantra ‘no publicity is bad publicity’, when you’re in the public service ‘thing’, a bad press always come back to haunt or bite you (seen it, been in the middle of it). Some folk just don’t get that.

      • Oh, standards in journalism started falling long ago. I got my training in the old school news gathering style, research, door stepping, ask a question, get an answer, ask it again and get it confirmed. Nowadays they just tap your phone.

      • There are some distant yet certain parallels with my job in the old HMIT (now HMRC).
        Read the letter.
        Look at the legislation.
        Write a draft (write it again more than once) ….dictate to a typist (who might well pick you up on your use of English).
        Send it out.
        Wait for the reply.
        And so forth.
        Now the Great Computers monitor any attempts are independent action.
        The opening of the Moondog’s “Stomping Ground” comes back to me on such occasions.
        “Machine were mice and men were lions
        Once upon a time
        But now that it’s the opposite
        It’s twice upon a time”

      • The miracle being that my little family survived intact.
        Some cossetted opinionated columnist (not for one of the ‘Big papers by the way). Said they did not understand. They had a wonderful time in the 80s- I extracted the page from the journal and savaged it

Leave a Reply to Tanya Cliff Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

The Alchemist's Studio

Raku pottery, vases, and gifts

Elegantly • Chaos

She made broken look beautiful and strong look invincible. She walked with the Universe on her shoulders and made it look like a pair of wings ...


Brett Kristian

Shreya Vikram

Blurring the lines between poetry and prose

Dining with Donald

Donald on Dining in and Out.

Help Me Believe

Strengthen the believer. Answer the critic.

Documentary Short Film Festival

Submit your short DOC and get it showcased at the FEEDBACK Film Festival


T.V/Movie News & Reviews

Vibe a Little

Learning to Live

A Blooming Scribe

Poetry, short essays and other work showcased by a Scientist, Philosopher, and Adventurer. Posts on Monday and First Fridays.


Natalia's space

V Ramasamy

A Globetrotter


An Empyrean Cycle

All in a Day's Breath

Art, Love of Life, Philosophy, Writing, Spirituality

Shiny Objects

Rambling ruminations


The conversations




Fiction is the ONLY Reality.


New content every Sunday.

%d bloggers like this: